Search
Cookie Usage Statistics Colour Key Sudden Death Monthly Poll Caption Comp eMail Author Shops
Ships Fleets Weaponry Species People Timelines Calculators Photo Galleries
Stations Design Lineage Size Charts Battles Science / Tech Temporal Styling Maps / Politics
Articles Reviews Lists Recreation Search Site Guide What's New Forum
Miscellaneous Ships
Dauntless Doomsday Machine 8472 Bioship 8472 Planetbuster Kumari class Angosian Ship Bajoran Assault Ship Bajoran Fighter Emissary Kendra Pagh Prophet Solar Sail Borg Cube Borg Probe Borg Sphere Borg Tactical Cube Borg Transwarp Prototype Borg Yacht Cardassian Dreadnought Cardassian Freighter Galor Hideki Keldon Cravic Ship Breen Frigate Dominion Attack Ship Dominion Battlecruiser Dominion Battleship Dominion Dreadnought Karemma Ship Yonada Air Tram Akira Ambassador Antares Centaur Challenger Cheyenne Class F Shuttle Constellation Constitution Constitution Daedalus Danube Defender Defiant Delta Flyer Endgame Nova Endgame Shuttle Excelsior Federation Federation Raider Federation Scout Federation Trainer Freedom Gage Galaxy Galaxy Yacht Griffin Hermes Holo Ship Intrepid Kelvin Luna Miranda Nebula New Orleans Niagara Norway Nova Oberth Olympic Orbital Shuttle Peregrine Polaris Prometheus Ptolemy Raven Refit Galaxy Rigel Saber Saladin Shelley Sovereign Sovereign Yacht Soyuz Springfield Steamrunner Sydney Travel Pod Trident Type 3 Shuttle Type 6 Shuttle Type 7 Shuttle Type 8 Shuttle Type 9 Shuttle Type 10 Shuttle Type 11 Shuttle Type 15 Shuttle Type 17 Shuttle Type 18 Shuttle Warp Sled Wells Work Bee Yeager D'Kora Hirogen Ship Ares Conestoga DY-100 Intrepid J Class Neptune NX Class NX Test Ship Saturn V SS Enterprise The Phoenix Type 0 Shuttle USS Enterprise Valiant Y Class Husnock Ship Kazon Raider Predator B'rel D'tai D-5 D-7 Early Bird of Prey K'pak K'T'Inga Klingon Bird of Prey Klingon Cargo Ship Klingon Tanker Negh'var Raptor Regency Voodieh Vor'cha Krenim Patrol Krenim Timeship Krenim Warship Malon Ship Mawasi Cruiser Eymorg Ship Nihydron Ship Pralor Ship Promellian Battlecruiser D'Deridex Early Bird of Prey Narada Norexan Romulan Bird of Prey Romulan D7 Romulan Science ship Romulan Scout Romulan Shuttle Scimitar Scorpion Son'a Battleship Son'a Collector Son'a Destroyer Cell Ship Module Ship Salvage Ship Observation Ship War Ship Tarellian Ship Early Tholian Ship V'Ger Whale Probe Varro Ship D'Kyr Sh'Raan Suurok Vahklas Vulcan Lander Xindi Aquatic Cruiser Xindi Arboreal Ship Xindi Insectoid Assault Ship Xindi Insectoid Fighter Xindi Insectoid Warship Xindi Primate Ship Xindi Primate Shuttle Xindi Reptilian Warship Zahl Ship Additional

Husnock Warship Weapon Power

The Survivers

Apart from the single Technical Manual reference to 1.02 Gigawatt phaser output, one of the problems with assigning high Terawatt figures to Star Trek ships lies in the episode 'The Survivors'. In this episode an image of a Husnock vessel created by a being known as a Douwd fires on the Enterprise-D. The following dialogue ensues :

Worf : "the vessel is firing jacketed streams of streams of positrons and anti protons. Equivalent firepower : forty megawatts. Shields are holding."
Vessel fires again
Worf : "Again, forty megawatts. No damage."
Riker : "Well if that's the best they can do this should last about five minutes."


inline image
The Husnock ship firing on the Enterprise. [1]



inline image
The effects of the weapon. [1]


Later in the episode the vessel returns and attacks again. This time :


Worf : "Shields are down. Captain, they hit us with four hundred gigawatts of particle energy!"
Picard : "Damage?"
Worf : "Superficial. But I am having trouble reassembling the shields."
Vessel fires again
Worf : "Shields down. There is thermal damage to the hull."
Data : "The warship is capable of striking us with far more powerful bursts."

There is no easy way to reconcile this number with any other value for weapons or shields - second attack was almost four hundred times as powerful as the Tech Manuals reference to the Type X phaser being 1.02 Gigawatts, and so even one or two shots should have overloaded the shields and destroyed the ship with ease - yet this doesn't happen. On the other hand, if the Type X is rated at 100,000 TW then a 400 GW beam should have no more effect than the 40 MW attack.
On the other hand, we know for a fact that different types and frequencies of energy can have different effects on Trek shielding - for example the Dominions Phased Polaron Beams passed through standard Federation shielding easily on their first encounter, but subsequent modifications to the shields made them far more resistant to these attacks. It is possible that the Husnock weapons were simply especially effective against shielding.

Overall I tend to put this incident down as a simple YATI (Yet Another Technical Inconsistency), but there is one possible way to reconcile it. I do NOT say that the following is what the authors had in mind, and I know it requires a slightly... imaginative interpretation of the dialogue. I simply offer it as a possibility.

The weapon fired antiprotons and positrons (anti-electorns), both forms of antimatter, jacketed inside something. Firing a pure antimatter beam at a shield would do nothing more or less than an equivalent beam composed of ordinary matter particles; given the dangers associated with storing and using antimatter, it seems pointless to use it in this way unless it gives some kind of advantage. So I suggest that what the antimatter stream was 'jacketed' with was a matter stream - this way, when the beam hits the shields the two streams would be brought together and annhilate each other, releasing a great deal of energy.

So what about the 400 GW reference? Well, I propose that this was the kinetic energy of the stream rather than the energy it released upon annhilation. To bring the shields down the Husnock fired a series of four pulses over approximately one second - I don't have the software needed to time it exactly, so I will assume that it is exactly one second.

If the Type X phaser is rated at 100,000 TW, then a Starship would consume 1.111 Kg of fuel per second to power that weapon. I'll assume that the Husnock weapon was, say, fifty times as powerful as this overall. In this case it would be firing a total of 55.555 Kg of matter and antimatter each second. So each shot would have a mass of 13.888 Kg and a kinetic energy of 100 GJ - and an detonation energy roughly equal to 4.6 photon torpedoes. The kinetic energy of the stream would be given by :
 
KE =0.5 x m x v2

So the velocity of the stream would be :
 
=(KE / (0.5 x m))0.5
 =(1 x 1011 / (0.5 x 13.888))0.5
 =(14.4 x 109)0.5
 =120,000 m/s

Now when we see the Husnock ship firing on the Enterprise, the pulses certainly look like they're going a lot slower than lightspeed - but of course special effects are not a very good indicator of this kind of thing (phasers travel at c, and they usually look quite slow on screen as well).

Conclusion

As noted, I tend to regard this whole thing as a simple YATI. But I think the idea that Worf was talking about the kinetic energy of the beam does hold water, at least to some extent - he said 'equivalent firepower' was 400 GW, but he didn't say what that was equivalent to, after all!


Colour key

Canon source Backstage source Novel source DITL speculation

References

# Series Season Source Comment
1 TNG 3 The Survivors
Series : TNG Season 3 (Disc 1)
Episode : The Survivors


© Graham & Ian Kennedy Page views : 46,384 Last updated : 17 Jan 2021