Search
Cookie Usage Statistics Colour Key Sudden Death Monthly Poll Caption Comp eMail Author Shops
Ships Fleets Weaponry Species People Timelines Calculators Photo Galleries
Stations Design Lineage Size Charts Battles Science / Tech Temporal Styling Maps / Politics
Articles Reviews Lists Recreation Search Site Guide What's New Forum
Bioship Planetbuster Assault Ship Fighter Emissary Kendra Pagh Prophet Solar Sail Additional Cube Probe Singularity Ship Sphere Tactical Cube Transwarp Prototype Yacht Dreadnought Freighter Galor Hideki Keldon Breen Frigate Attack Ship Battlecruiser Battleship Dreadnought Karemma Ship Air Tram Akira Ambassador Antares Centaur Challenger Cheyenne Class F Shuttle Constellation Constitution Constitution Daedalus Danube Defender Defiant Delta Flyer Endgame Nova Endgame Shuttle Excelsior Excelsior II Excelsior Variant 1 Federation Class Raider Scout Trainer Freedom Gagarin Gage Galaxy Galaxy Yacht Griffin Hermes Holo Ship Intrepid Kelvin Luna Miranda Nebula New Orleans Niagara Norway Nova Oberth Olympic Orbital Shuttle Peregrine Polaris Prometheus Ptolemy Raven Refit Galaxy Reliant Rigel Ross Saber Sagan Saladin Shelley Sovereign Sovereign Yacht Soyuz Springfield Steamrunner Sutherland Sydney Travel Pod Trident Type 3 Shuttle Type 6 Shuttle Type 7 Shuttle Type 8 Shuttle Type 9 Shuttle Type 10 Shuttle Type 11 Shuttle Type 14 Shuttle Type 15 Shuttle Type 17 Shuttle Type 18 Shuttle Warp Sled Wells Work Bee Yeager Additional D'Kora Additional Ares Conestoga DY-100 Intrepid J Class Neptune NX Class NX Test Ship Saturn V SS Enterprise The Phoenix Type 0 Shuttle USS Enterprise Valiant Y Class Additional Raider Predator Additional B'rel D'tai D-5 D-7 Early Bird of Prey K'pak K'T'Inga Bird of Prey Cargo Ship Tanker Negh'var Raptor Regency Voodieh Vor'cha Additional D'Deridex Early Bird of Prey Narada Norexan Bird of Prey D7 Science ship Scout Shuttle Scimitar Scorpion Additional Battleship Collector Destroyer Additional Cell Ship Module Ship Salvage Ship Additional Observation Ship War Ship Additional D'Kyr Sh'Raan Suurok Vahklas Lander Additional Aquatic Cruiser Arboreal Ship Insectoid Assault Ship Insectoid Fighter Insectoid Warship Primate Ship Primate Shuttle Reptilian Warship Additional Dauntless Doomsday Machine Kumari class Angosian Ship Cravic Ship Yonada Hirogen Ship Husnock Ship Krenim Patrol Krenim Timeship Krenim Warship Malon Ship Mawasi Cruiser Eymorg Ship Nihydron Ship Pralor Ship Promellian Battlecruiser Tarellian Ship Early Tholian Ship V'Ger Whale Probe Varro Ship Zahl Ship Additional

Who Mourns for Adonais?

ReviewImagesDatapointsQuotesMorals
TimelinePreviousNextYour View
Series :
Season Ep :
2 x 04
Title :
Who Mourns for Adonais?
Rating :
3
Overall Ep :
34
First Aired :
22 Sep 1967
Stardate :
3468.1
Director :
Year :
Writers :
Your Rating :
1.0000 for 1 reviews
Reviewer : Indefatigable Rating : 1
Review : An interesting concept, that ancient mythology was based on alien visitors to Earth. Possibly "Chariots of the Gods" was an inspiration for it, but it was worth exploring. However, they did not do it very well. The classical references seem reasonably accurate (although there was no mention of the Sun). Incidentally, Pollux IV was an interesting choice, being both a real star(Beta Geminorum) and Apollo's half-brother in mythology. Still, for all that, the script was not particularly good. Apollo demanded something that Humanity could no longer give, and Kirk made sure that he did not get it. So, they were captured and freed themselves again, simple enough. Lieutenant Palamas was once again a bit of a pushover, something from the script even before they met Apollo, but she just got swept away until Kirk swept her back. It is possibly understandable what she saw in the situation, but there was no particular reason for anyone else to be tempted, which would have been far better. As it was, all the others could see was a prison. Scotty (who should not really be on a landing party) let his jealousy go far too far and simply served as a convenient subject to get beaten up. The hand in space was effective, and the new visualisations captured it well. However, that does not make up for the basic failings. A weak episode.
Add your own review

© Graham & Ian Kennedy Page views : 7,997 Last updated : 26 Apr 2024