www.ditl.org

Gorn Vs Kirk, Minus the gunpowder, the outcome, BAM! discuss...

following quote taken from StarDestroyer BBS, a response to someone who called that scene the worst fight scene ever "Shatner vs a dinosaur should be called the best fight ever. But haters gotta hate."

I doubt Kirk would've won without the bamboo cannon.

I guess if he'd waited until the sun went down, and the place got down around freezing, he could've just bashed the Gorn repeatedly with a rock while it was immobile...

Assuming it wasn't endothermic. Remember, Gorn appear reptilian, but they're not from Earth.

Meh. Sooner or later, Kirk would have torn his shirt - at which point, it would've been all over for the Gorn.

Mikey wrote:Assuming it wasn't endothermic. Remember, Gorn appear reptilian, but they're not from Earth.

Good point.

The problem with this question is that Kirk outthought his opponent, and thus won. The Gorn could just as easily made the same sort of weapon, but didn't....opting for a stone knife and using his natural strength. They don't like Kirks solution? Ok....but what are they looking for? Kirk and the Gorn going strictly hand to hand? Kirk had no chance to win that kind of encounter, so why fight it? He was fighting for his life and the lives of his crew.

But, as we've seen in other episodes Kirk can improvise. Take away the gunpowder, and he could have made a bow and arrow. Unless that would be the next thing disallowed.

Making it strictly hand to hand, no weapons allowed, means that Kirk is screwed completely. The fight was very much of the brains versus brawn variety.

A thought hit me. What are the odds that if the Gorn Captain killed Kirk, he would have spared the crew of the Enterprise?

Hard to say. We know pretty much nothing about Gorn society, so it's difficult to tell how they'd treat the crew of the Enterprise after what occurred on the surface. Maybe they'd consider it the ultimate dishonour if their captain had destroyed the Enterprise after already killing its captain. Maybe they'd have blown the ship up to re-affirm the whole "this is our territory" thing. Maybe they'd have tried to board them and seize the E.

Hard to say. We know pretty much nothing about Gorn society, so it's difficult to tell how they'd treat the crew of the Enterprise after what occurred on the surface. Maybe they'd consider it the ultimate dishonour if their captain had destroyed the Enterprise after already killing its captain. Maybe they'd have blown the ship up to re-affirm the whole "this is our territory" thing. Maybe they'd have tried to board them and seize the E.

Hard to say. We know pretty much nothing about Gorn society, so it's difficult to tell how they'd treat the crew of the Enterprise after what occurred on the surface. Maybe they'd consider it the ultimate dishonour if their captain had destroyed the Enterprise after already killing its captain. Maybe they'd have blown the ship up to re-affirm the whole "this is our territory" thing. Maybe they'd have tried to board them and seize the E.

And SG gets another triple this season. Folks, I think he's going for the record!

I think we should divide his post count my three, just for that.


Who am I kidding? I'm just jealous that he can have multiples..........

I blame my internet connection. It's been acting funny for a while now.

Sionnach Glic wrote:I blame my internet connection. It's been acting funny for a while now.

You haven't got a new modem by any chance? One with "made in France" on it?