Why does everyone love the original TOS Enterprise so much?

[Aaron]

They can?
Jesus, never would have guessed that.

Seawolf was designed to carry fifty weapons (so close) in her magazine and the newly refitted Ohio SSGN's can carry 154 Tomahawks plus there normal loadout of torpedos. So whatever space SF is dedicating to a PT magazine, it isn't very large.

[Sionnach Glic]

Aye, pretty pathetic when you put it like that.

[LaughingCheese]

I find that to be one of the most annoying things about the E-D. Yeah, I have a whole list of complaints about the ship, but just storing 250 torps is excesively stupid.

I suppose the only real explanation could be that Starfleet is primarily exploratory, i.e., they aren't expecting major conflicts (and thus aren't prepared for them! ).


So, what about 10,000 per PT/QT launcher?

[Sionnach Glic]

Given that Starfleet is the UFP's first line of defence and only military force, it would be highly stupid of them to just ignore military concerns. Particularly when they're surrounded on all sides by hostile and expansionist powers. Hell, just look at the amount of wars the UFP's been in.

Of course, it's quite possible they did do it for just that reason. We do have Picard's quote about tactics not being thought to captains, and he's commander of the UFP flagship and the most powerful ship in Starfleet.

[Graham Kennedy]

One thing to bear in mind is that 250 is how many torpedoes the ship had aboard in Conundrum. We have no idea if that is their maximum capacity. Any military types around here know if modern Naval vessels always sail with their magazines full, or do they sometimes go out with only partial armament?

Also, it may be a matter of torpedo casings vs probe casings. Perhaps the GCS's normal peacetime fit is 250 photons and 1,750 probes?

On the other hand, when Voyager went on her first mission she was going into disputed territory against a known hostile force, and she only had 38 photons. I'd expect that to be either her maximum complement or close to it given the mission. And if Voyager is that limited, 250 would certainly be a reasonable figure for a Galaxy.

[Sionnach Glic]

I think the idea that the UFP is suffering from a shortage of anit-matter fits this nicely. They're using so much to power their ships, that they can't build many torpedoes.

[Graham Kennedy]

Don't they use the same tanks to supply ships and torps?

[Aaron]

One thing to bear in mind is that 250 is how many torpedoes the ship had aboard in Conundrum. We have no idea if that is their maximum capacity. Any military types around here know if modern Naval vessels always sail with their magazines full, or do they sometimes go out with only partial armament?

Again, that depends. Most Western naval SAM's are actually dual-purpose so there isn't a driving need to carry a crap load of SSM's. But most US vessels carry a full loadout, yes.

[Mikey]

Don't they use the same tanks to supply ships and torps?

One would think so, but I don't recall hearing any canon on the matter one way or the other.

whateverthehellium

I take a new multi-vitamin with 120% RDA of whateverthehellium. I've never felt better.

[Graham Kennedy]

I take a new multi-vitamin with 120% RDA of whateverthehellium. I've never felt better.

It's good for what ails you.

[LaughingCheese]

I take a new multi-vitamin with 120% RDA of whateverthehellium. I've never felt better.

I just eat straight cheese. 8)

[Mark]

You know, I was just looking at the name of the thread, and it hit me. It fired the imagination. Something about a ship built of odd geometrical shapes with old FX just sparked my imagination. And in TMP when we saw her refit for the first time, she looked, for lack of a better term, proud. Sounds dumb I know, but it just hit me and I wanted to share that before it drifted away in a puff of smoke from my ears.

[Sionnach Glic]

Don't they use the same tanks to supply ships and torps?

Possibly. I can't imagine SF would be stupid enough to ship them out loaded full of highly volatile materials.

[Mikey]

You know, I was just looking at the name of the thread, and it hit me. It fired the imagination. Something about a ship built of odd geometrical shapes with old FX just sparked my imagination. And in TMP when we saw her refit for the first time, she looked, for lack of a better term, proud. Sounds dumb I know, but it just hit me and I wanted to share that before it drifted away in a puff of smoke from my ears.

No, you're right. Someone (GK, I believe) mentioned that one of the great things about the E-nil design was how different it was from any pre-existing sci-fi spaceship. It wasn't just a "flying saucer," or a Flash Gordon phallic symbol.

[Sionnach Glic]

Aye, it was probably the first design that made people sit up and go "hey, that looks pretty cool".