Star Trek XI

[Sionnach Glic]

By all means, please explain how having massively long explainations when simple, short, explainations could suffice would contribute to the story in any way.
And besides, there was no real technobabble in TOS.

[Grundig]

I can at least imagine why the writers put the stuff in. 1) They want their wacky idea to sound believable 2) They're following a tradition by using it.

TNG was the worst. I think Voyager was almost as bad. Somehow, DS9 got away with alot less, IIRC. TOS was great, because all you needed was Scotty screaming and pulling his hair out to get the message across that the ship's in trouble. Ent was OK, but not great in this regard.

[Mikey]

I'm with Seafort on this. There are times when "proper" technobabble can be used to indicate the advanced nature of science and technology - but often, it is used in a way which makes it obvious that it is being used to obfuscate the fact that no attempt was made to correlate real science with the writing.

[Graham Kennedy]

I have no problem with them talking about science and technology to some extent, what's important is how they do it. You don't need to say "The enemy is disrupting our communications by generating a rotating quantum inversion field!" - you just need to say "They're jamming us!" It conveys the exact same information to the audience, without leaving them thinking "um... a what?"

[Reliant121]

I have to agree with GK.

[Sionnach Glic]

Aye, I agree wtih that, too. Just say what is happening (ie, the warp core is going to blow). Don't go on a long description of how and why it's happening, unless it does something to further the plot.

[Graham Kennedy]

That's one thing I liked about Generations. Geordi didn't give a big long speech about safety systems being offline, and core ejections systems being jammed, and all that. He just said "We have a coolant leak, we're three minutes away from a warp core breach, and there's nothing I can do."

Yet people complained about it. Go figure.

[stitch626]

I loved that part because of the lack of TB.

[Sionnach Glic]

Aye, more writers should do things that way.

[thelordharry]

Shatner's surprising reaction to Chris Pine being cast in his former role

[Tsukiyumi]

Shatner's surprising reaction to Chris Pine being cast in his former role