OMG
I couldn't get past the first part.
Did he ever hear of M=l*F.

Anyone of the better trek shuttle designes is superior to any APC.
It has superior firepower.
Superior shielding.
Superior mobility.

All I know about is Picard stating that Federation worlds are spread across 8000ly These quote from Picard can only be used to detrmine the maximum size of the federation. Kinda like a flatten ball with a diameter of 4000ly and a hight of 500ly. People usually assume Federation can be approximated ...

Starfury a great designe. It basicly made the EA a superpower. It won the Dilgar war. Come in 3 models. The standart, the heavy version with the tailgunner and thunderbolt. Thunderbolt was capable of atmosferic flight, did that in any way effect its space performence? It was weaker than the Mimbari ...

Exactly. Yet a scratch to the nacelle made the unconnected core go boom And how in the hell does warp plasma get to the necells. As to the car analogy - it's false. Ok. when deaths or injuries can be attributed to a vehicle's design, rather than operator error, the design is fixed or scrapped. The ...

Irrelevent. How is it irelevent? If the attacker can't access the ship's computer he can't plant his virus True. Now show an instance when someone on the same technological level hacked the computer. if the computer won't run the code the virus Ok. As I saide send a todays virus through a 10 years ...

A Wall of Ignorance is another name for "ignoring people's points and stating the same thing again". Ok. So the anomaly mysteriously made the nacelles a few thousand times weaker?. Where did I claime that. There is no damage done to the necells. I can see it disrupting power systems Like ...

no ship historically has ever been lost due to it's engines exploding The fuel used is antimater. No I didn't think so. decent computer security would make the lies of what happened to the Yamato impossible. Yes if the technology would be at the same level. Not if one is thouseds of years more adva...

Anomaly: I can Somewhat accept that one Its the only plosible explanation. Computer virus: It should never have been downloaded into either the Yamato or the Enterprise in the first place. Thats like saying, computers are still effective and safe if a trojan horse can get to them because they have ...

In the movies and now in the new CGI cartoon there are a few examples when the Jedi a surprised that the CIS, had some information so that they were able to stop an offencive escape,.. so without the flow of informations from Palpine the CIS would be overun.

Her role's pretty obvious once you a) take a look at the Federation's economic ad politic system in TNG (i.e. Communism) and b) look at who's usually spouting the party line about war, poverty, despair, etc being eliminated. She's a political commissar. Or you take a look at what her job is, how ma...

I want to play too :wave: Is that a joke? It started out as a joke but than got a life. Please, we've discussed this ad nauseum I know but there is no harm in doing it againe. It is well publicized here (in discussions of which you were a part, IIRC) what some of the criticisms of the GCS are. Isn't...

2 pages allredy damm thats quick. Saying that they were better than anything else, or that they performed well, doesn't negate the fact that there were problems to be corrected. And what are some of the problems, just for fun. That says more about the shitastic state that Starfleet was in prior to t...

GCS is alway good for a great party.

Like I saide. One line and you have a totaly new topic.

But hey like it or not.
The GCS were:
The most heavaly armed
The most heavaly shielded
the fasted ships at the time.
And during the Dominion war they were the center piece of every fleet action and they performed greate.