| Mobile Site | Caption Comp | Monthly Poll | Sudden Death | Book Reviews | Game Reviews | Colour Key | Statistics | Cookie Usage |
Guest Review |
| Title : | North Star | Rating : |  |
| First Aired : | 12 Nov 2003 | Stardate : | Unknown |
| Director : | David Straiton | Year : | 2153 |
| Writers : | David A. Goodman | Season : | 3 |
| Rating : | 2.5000 for 2 reviews | Add your own review | |
| Reviewer : | Tyyrlym | Rating : |  |
| Review : | A fun episode in TOS vibe. There's quite a few "wha...?" moments however. Where did Enterprise get the guns? How are there only 6,000 humans after two centuries on the planet? Why did they halt their development? Lots of very huh questions, but no more than your average Hollywood action flick. While those questions exist the episode is fun and still manages to remain a good strong Trek vibe. | ||
| Reviewer : | Indefatigable | Rating : | |
| Review : | Trek does the Wild West yet again. In this case, it's a bit more interesting than usual, but not very much so. The odd thing really was the different attitudes in pre-Prime Directive days (which would not apply for a lost Human colony anyway). I really mean the moment when Archer beams himself and the girl up in front of half the village. T'pol seems to be trying to follow some form of non-interference rule, but I'm not sure what it is. Still, Earth now has a nice little colony out in the Expanse. If anyone works out how to get in and out, then I wonder if they will try to hang on to the planet. Verdict, OK, but not brilliant. | ||
| Copyright Graham Kennedy | Page views : 845 | Last updated : 1 Jan 1970 |
