Search
Mobile Site Caption Comp Monthly Poll Sudden Death Book Reviews Game Reviews Colour Key Statistics Cookie Usage
Federation Ships Other Ships A-K Fleets Weaponry Species Standard People Timelines Calculators Photo Galleries Temporal
Space Stations Other Ships L-Z Design Lineage Size Charts Battles Alternate People Science / Tech Styling Maps / Politics Temporal Ships
Articles Reviews Lists Recreation Search Site Guide What's New eMail Author Links / Awards Shops Forum
Federation
Ships
Air
Tram

Akira

Ambassador

Antares

Argo

Centaur

Challenger

Cheyenne

Constellation

Constitution

Daedalus

Danube

Defender

Defiant
Delta
Flyer

Excelsior

Federation

Freedom

Gage

Galaxy
Galaxy
Yacht

Griffin

Hermes
Holo
Ship

Intrepid

Kelvin

Luna

Miranda

Nebula
New
Orleans

Niagara

Norway

Nova

Oberth

Olympic
Orbital
Shuttle

Peregrine

Polaris

Prometheus

Ptolemy

Raider

Raven

Rigel

Saber

Saladin

Scout

Shelley

Sovereign
Sovereign
Yacht

Soyuz

Springfield

Steamrunner

Sydney

Trainer
Travel
Pod

Trident
Type 1
Shuttle
Type 3
Shuttle
Type 6
Shuttle
Type 7
Shuttle
Type 8
Shuttle
Type 9
Shuttle
Type 10
Shuttle
Type 11
Shuttle
Type 15
Shuttle
Type 18
Shuttle
Warp
Sled
Work
Bee

Yeager

Additional
PreviousNextTimeline
ReviewImagesDatapointsGuests

Countdown

Review

Series : Enterprise Rating : 3
Disc No : 3.6 Episode : 75
First Aired : 19 May 2004 Stardate : Unknown
Director : Robert Duncan McNeill Year : 2154
Writers : AndrĂ© Bormanis, Chris Black Season : 3
Guest Cast :
Andrew Borba as Reptilian Lieutenant
Bruce Thomas as Reptilian Soldier
Dorenda Moore as S. Money
Josette DiCarlo as Sphere-Builder Woman
Marco Sanchez as Corporal Romero
Mary Mara as Sphere-Builder Presage
Paul Dean as Reptilian Technician
Paul Sklar as Corporal R. Richards
Rick Worthy as Jannar
Ruth Williamson as Sphere-Builder Primary
Scott MacDonald as Commander Dolim
Steven Culp as Major Hayes
Tucker Smallwood as Xindi-Humanoid
YATI : Archer takes the injured and possibly brain damaged Hoshi along for her knowledge of the weapon systems and codes. Huh? Why doesn't he just ask the Xindi for the information he needs? They built the thing!
Great Moment :
Body Count : Lots of ships destroyed; dozens, maybe hundreds of casualties are likely. Major Hayes is killed rescuing Hoshi.
Factoid :
Quote :

Plotline

Archer and the Xindi council launch an attack on the stolen weapon, hoping to destroy it before the brainwashed Hoshi can break the codes needed to arm it. Meanwhile T'Pol and Trip devise a plan to destroy one of the spheres, hoping it will disrupt the entire network. Faced with defeat, the sphere builders decided to take direct action.

Analysis

I'm beginning to dislike the way the Reptilians are being portrayed. So far they have been shown as being aggressive, violent, and single-minded. As far as they are concerned Humans are guilty, the evidence says so and that's that. But in the last episode or two, we have the Reptilians confronted by so much evidence that we either have to believe that they are also incredibly stupid to keep thinking that Earth is their enemy, or they actually don't care.

In this episode the Reptilian Commander is faced with direct, irrefutable evidence that the trans-dimensional aliens really are in control of the spheres - evidence that even convinces the Insectoids they are on the wrong side. Yet he doesn't even question what he is doing, he simply attacks the Insectoids and carries on regardless, threatening death to his own crew if they even question the aliens.

We have seen plenty of 'evil' species before on Enterprise, so there is nothing really wrong or impossible about the Reptilian attitude, but I found the Xindi much more interesting when they were misguided people who genuinely believed they were doing a horrible thing because it was an awful necessity. Now it looks like the Reptilian is trying to destroy Earth basically for kicks, or just because he's been told to do it by the people who he must know, deep down inside, are actually responsible for the destruction of his species. It makes them a lot less interesting.


Copyright Graham Kennedy Page views : 1,955 Last updated : 23 May 2004