Search
Mobile Site Caption Comp Monthly Poll Sudden Death Colour Key Statistics Cookie Usage
Federation Ships Other Ships A-K Fleets Weaponry Species Standard People Timelines Calculators Photo Galleries Temporal
Space Stations Other Ships L-Z Design Lineage Size Charts Battles Alternate People Science / Tech Styling Maps / Politics Temporal Ships
Articles Reviews Lists Recreation Search Site Guide What's New eMail Author Links / Awards Shops Forum

Species

8472

Andorians

Armus

Ba'ku

Bajorans

Benzites

Betazoids

Bolians

Borg

Breen

Bynars

Cardassians

Cheronians
Crystalline
entity

Demons

Denobulans

Douwd

Edo

El-Aurians

Ferengi

Founders

Gomtuu

Gorn

Hierarchy

Hirogen

Horta

Humans

Hunters

J'Naii

Jem'Hadar

Karemma

Kataanians

Kazon

Kelvans

Klingons

Kobali

Kriosians

Ktarians

Lurians

Malon
Morg /
Eymorg

Na'kuhl

Nagilum

Nanites

Nausicaans

Ocampa

Organians

Orions
Pah-
wraiths

Pakled

Parasites

Progenitors

Prophets

Q

Remans

Risans

Romulans

Scalosians

Sheliak

Sikarians

Son'a
Space
Jellyfish
Sphere
Builders

Suliban

Talaxians

Talosians

Tamarians
Tarchannen
parasites

Tellarites
The
Cloud

Tholians

Tosk

Tribbles

Trill

Vaadwaur

Vidiians

Vissians

Vorta

Voth

Vulcans

Xindi

Yridians

Zalkonians
Additional
Species
PreviousNextTimeline
ReviewImagesDatapointsYour View

North Star

Review

Series : Enterprise Rating : 2
Disc No : 3.3 Episode : 61
First Aired : 12 Nov 2003 Stardate : Unknown
Director : David Straiton Year : 2153
Writers : David A. Goodman Season : 3
Guest Cast :
Alexandria M. Salling as Taliyah
Cliff McLaughlin as Cowboy #2
Dorenda Moore as S. Money
Emily Bergl as Bethany
Gary Bristow as Stablehand
Glenn Morshower as Sheriff MacReady
James Parks as Deputy Bennings
Jeff Eith as Cowboy #1
Jon Baron as Skagaran Boy
Kevin Derr as G. Austin
Mike Watson as Skagaran
Paul Rae as Bartender
Steven Klein as Draysik
Tom Dupont as Cowboy #3
YATI : It makes no sense that the Humans here are stuck in the old west after all this time. They obviously have the capacity to manufacture guns, which means that they have factories, metallurgy, chemistry, and engineers and scientists to make it all work. If so, then there is no reason why their technology shouldn't improve over time. Okay with a small population base maybe they wouldn't have advanced to the point of building Starships or anything, but they certainly should have got well beyond the whole western thing.

Also, where did Archer and Trip get their guns from? Can Enterprise manufacture stuff like this without replicator technology? Or does Reed have an ancient weapon collection like Worf did?

Great Moment : Archer wins another fight, even after being shot! Plus I also liked Reed's "shoot the hostage" solution to T'Pol being captured. Direct, sensible, practical, and it involved shooting people - a perfect Reed plan.
Body Count : One alien hung at the beginning. Several people are – presumably – stunned during the battle, including T'Pol by Reed. Bethany is shot but recovers, Archer got shot in the shoulder but recovers.
Factoid : Archer was born in upstate New York.
Quote : "They kidnapped the wrong people." - Archer to T'Pol; Yay humans!

Plotline

Enterprise discovers a planet in the Expanse which has six thousand Humans living on it. The Humans have re-created the American old west, complete with an alien species which functions as slaves. Archer must decide whether to reveal the truth about Earth to the inhabitants of a local town, a decision complicated by a deputy sheriff with a habit of lynching those he doesn't get on with.


Copyright Graham Kennedy Page views : 3,315 Last updated : 24 Nov 2014