No, we saw a Starfleet ship that knew exactly where to target to do the most damage blasting holes in the Connie's engineering section.Duskofdead wrote:Again, because those ships faced different circumstances. We didn't see a vastly superior alien ship cutting into the Constitution's engineering section.
No, we saw an identical nacelle ripped apart by phaser and torpedo fire.We didn't see a ship collide into its nacelles.
See above. And TWOK.So the comparison is flawed, we didn't see two ships of the same era facing very similar threats/situations.
I repeat Rochey's request*snip waffle*
Show me a single example of any of us simply waving away your points without backing up our arguments.