Yes, Janeway's Worst Command Decisions

[RK_Striker_JK_5]

I'm not adding breathing, being born or anything like that for any of the captains, though.

[Lt. Staplic]

you should make an exception.

[Sonic Glitch]

I'm not adding breathing, being born or anything like that for any of the captains, though.

And to be fair to the spirit of the question: it (fortunately or unfortunately as the case may be) was not her decision to be born or to breath. And before someone says you can stop your breathing, you can only do so for so long before some sort of something (i forget the term) is triggered in, i believe the base of the brain, to breath again.

[Lt. Staplic]

I'm not adding breathing, being born or anything like that for any of the captains, though.

And to be fair to the spirit of the question: it (fortunately or unfortunately as the case may be) was not her decision to be born or to breath. And before someone says you can stop your breathing, you can only do so for so long before some sort of something (i forget the term) is triggered in, i believe the base of the brain, to breath again.

she chose to open her f*****g mouth.

[RK_Striker_JK_5]

you should make an exception.

lol, maybe. But then I'd have to add it to Kirk, Picard and Sisko to be fair.

[SomosFuga]

Help the vaadwaur "Dragon's Teeth"
Give holographic technology to the hirogen.
Resurrect neelix "Mortal Coil"
Not to release the hirogen and get away that place knowing other ships were coming "Pray"
Not terminate the drone fetus at once "Drone"
Delete Holo Crell Moset "Nothing Human"

[Granitehewer]

disagree re: ''drone'', don't think that ethically she could do that

[Tyyr]

And regardless I really wouldn't classify that as Janeway's worst decision. She did a LOT stupider things in her time.

[Granitehewer]

sorry if its already here, and have skipped over it, but crapping myself about the presentation tomorrow, but what about janeways's decisions in ''in the flesh'' and ''scorpion''...?

[RK_Striker_JK_5]

Okay, then...


1) Destroying the array ("Caretaker")
2) Allowing Neelix to stay onboard ("Caretaker")
3) Making Torres Chief Engineer ("Parallax")
4) Releasing the Viidians ("The Phage")
5) Not asking Q to send them home ("Death Wish")
6) Chasing after Chakotay's supposed son ("Basics")
7) Barging into Swarm space ("The Swarn")
8) Trying to grab the Ferengi instead of just heading home ("False Profits")
9) Not asking Q to send them home ("The Q and the Grey")
10) Not kicking Neelix off the ship for lying to her, theft, etc ("Fair Trade")
11) Preventing the destruction of the Borg ("Scorpion")
12) Barging into Bo'mar space ("The Raven")
13) Continuing to try and get through Krenim space after the first attack ("Year of Hell")
14) Charging through a dangerous nebula ("One")
15) Not destroying the telepathic monolith ("Memorial")
16) Allowing Harry Kim to drag Voyager into a war ("Nightingale")
17) Not pestering Q more about getting them home ("Q2")
18) Not shoving Neelix out of an airlock.
19) Killing Tuvix.
20)Help the vaadwaur "Dragon's Teeth"
21)Give holographic technology to the hirogen.
22)Resurrect neelix "Mortal Coil"
23)Not to release the hirogen and get away that place knowing other ships were coming "Pray"
24)Not terminate the drone fetus at once "Drone"
25)Delete Holo Crell Moset "Nothing Human"

Wow, hell of a list. I think this is more than the other four combined.

[Tyyr]

Because Janeway was a really, really bad captain who should have known better.

Archer was a worse captain but you can only expect so much from a bigoted, retarded, moron.

[Reliant121]

And to be fair, the level of training he would have got would have been much much worse for the pure fact that no-one had ever really done his job before. Sure, commanding system limited ships, but not the first properly interstellar explorer.

Although it would have been good if he had common sense.

[Captain Seafort]

disagree re: ''drone'', don't think that ethically she could do that

Why not - it was a Borg.

[Mark]

21)Give holographic technology to the hirogen.

You know, I'm going to disagree with this one. As far as her WORST decisions at least. Giving the Hirogen that tech saved a great number of lives across the GQ. It's not her fault the Hirogen didn't delete the cookies on the holodeck and let them become self aware.

[RK_Striker_JK_5]

List finalized and sent in. Thanks.