Star Trek is fantasy

[Sionnach Glic]

That David Brin guy is a moron. I've run across some of his stuff before, and he seems to be having a go at anyone whose works are more popular than his, including Lucas and Tolkein.

[Mikey]

That David Brin guy is a moron. I've run across some of his stuff before, and he seems to be having a go at anyone whose works are more popular than his, including Lucas and Tolkein.

Considering the fact that I'd never heard of him until now, and I am fairly well-read, I'd say the set of "anyone whose works are more popular than his" is a large set indeed.

[Blackstar the Chakat]

I really really hate it when people clump Star Trek, or sci-fi in general, with fantasy series. I want to strangle people who do that. That kind of comparision can be made to any series. I could probably make fantasy look like sci-fi if I tried. (there's no such thing as magic )

[Mikey]

I really really hate it when people clump Star Trek, or sci-fi in general, with fantasy series. I want to strangle people who do that. That kind of comparision can be made to any series. I could probably make fantasy look like sci-fi if I tried. (there's no such thing as magic )

Yep. Although I really don't have the inclination to strangle anyone, I could if I were so inclined probably draw parallels to make a cookbook look like fantasy.

[Sionnach Glic]

Indeed. Like it was said earlier: if you look hard enough you could compare sci-fi to anything.

[Captain Picard's Hair]

Indeed. Like it was said earlier: if you look hard enough you could compare sci-fi to anything.

Porn is like sci fi because...

[Sionnach Glic]

Well, the ship is smooth, like a woman's body, and.......

[Blackstar the Chakat]

Indeed. Like it was said earlier: if you look hard enough you could compare sci-fi to anything.

Porn is like sci fi because...

Well Picard did ram his long hard ship into the Scimitar

[Aaron]

Considering the fact that I'd never heard of him until now, and I am fairly well-read, I'd say the set of "anyone whose works are more popular than his" is a large set indeed.

He's responsible for The Postman. Which while a decent movie is no SW, ST or Firefly.

[Mikey]

Considering the fact that I'd never heard of him until now, and I am fairly well-read, I'd say the set of "anyone whose works are more popular than his" is a large set indeed.

He's responsible for The Postman. Which while a decent movie is no SW, ST or Firefly.

I wouldn't even consider it a Rollerball.

[Sionnach Glic]

Personaly, I thought that movie was pretty bad.

[Mikey]

Personaly, I thought that movie was pretty bad.

Do you mean The Postman or Rollerball?

[Graham Kennedy]

I've read a fair bit of Brin's stuff, I rate him as pretty good actually. His Uplift universe is a great scenario, and some of the books set in it are amongst my favourites - though some are decidedly not.

He doesn't get to decide what 'true' sci fi is, to be sure. He has as much right to his opinion as anybody, though.

[Mikey]

He doesn't get to decide what 'true' sci fi is, to be sure. He has as much right to his opinion as anybody, though.

No doubt. My only point is that he has no right to MY opinion.

[Sionnach Glic]

Do you mean The Postman or Rollerball?

The Postman. Never saw Rollerball.