Search
Mobile Site Caption Comp Monthly Poll Sudden Death Book Reviews Game Reviews Colour Key Statistics Cookie Usage
Federation Ships Other Ships A-K Fleets Weaponry Species Standard People Timelines Calculators Photo Galleries Temporal
Space Stations Other Ships L-Z Design Lineage Size Charts Battles Alternate People Science / Tech Styling Maps / Politics Temporal Ships
Articles Reviews Lists Recreation Search Site Guide What's New eMail Author Links / Awards Shops Forum

Articles
Abrams
Speed!

Antimatter
Borg
History
Constitution
Class Starships
Dangling
Threads
Enterprise
Ramblings
Eugenics
War Dates
Here be
Remans?
Klingon
Battlecruiser
Klingon
Bird of Prey
Live fast...
Write Badly
Magazine
Capacity

Maps

Money

Monoculture
Nemesis
Script
NX Class
Phase Cannon

Phasers
Random
Musings
Religion
in Trek
Romulan
Warp Drive
Scaling
Issues
Size of the
Federation
Sovereign
Changes

Stardates
Technology
Levels
The Ba'Ku
Land Grab
The
Defiant
The
Holodeck
The Size of
Starfleet
Torpedo
Yields
Transwarp
Theories
Trek XI
Issues
Tri-cobalt
device
Trills
/ Dax
Warp Speed
Anomalies
Total
Output
Galaxy Class
Total Output
Intrepid Class
Total Output
Weapon
Power
D'Deridex Class
Weapon Power
Galaxy Class
Weapon Output
Genesis
Weapon Power
Husnock Warship
Weapon Power
TOS Type 2 Phaser
Weapon Power
Trilithium Torpedoes
Weapon Power
Shield
Strength
Galaxy Class
Shield Strength

Miscellaneous

Materials
PreviousNextTimeline
ReviewImagesDatapoints

Proving Ground

Series : Enterprise Rating : 3
Disc No : 3.4 Episode : 65
First Aired : 21 Jan 2004 Stardate : 6-Dec-53
Director : David Livingston Year : 2153
Writers : Chris Black Season : 3
Guest Cast :
Granville Van Dusen as Andorian General
Jeffrey Combs as Shran
Josh Drennen as Degra's Assistant
Molly Brink as Talas
Randy Oglesby as Degra
Rick Worthy as Jannar
Scott MacDonald as Commander Dolim
Tucker Smallwood as Xindi-Humanoid
Guest Reviews :
Rating : 4.0000 for 1 reviewsView existing reviewsAdd your own review
YATI : Not necessarily a nit, but the Xindi prototype seems awfully small. This thing fitted into Shran's ship, and was expected to fit into Enterprise's launch bay. Yet the full weapon we saw in Twilight was huge, much larger than the Xindi ships accompanying it. Isn't a prototype supposed to be a close match to the final product?
Great Moment : Shran's antennae appearing over Archer's head, a laugh-out-loud moment!
Body Count : One Enterprise crewman falls off a catwalk when they hit the anomaly, level of injury unknown; otherwise none.
Factoid : Andorian antennae are remote controlled; the actors have a small unit under the hair on the back of their heads, and two people stand off-screen to move them around.

This is the first episode to show us the inside of an Andorian ship.

Quote : "Take us out of the system. But not too quickly; the Andorian mining consortium runs from no-one!" – Shran, taking his role as a miner just a little too seriously.

Plotline

Enterprise locates the kemocite signature that Gralik planted in the shipment of weapons material for them. On the way to investigate the ship is disabled by an anomaly, but at the last moment they are rescued by Shran, an Andorian Archer has dealt with on several prior occasions. Shran is here to help with the Xindi in return for Archer's past favours, and together the two ships locate the site of a new Xindi test of their prototype weapon. The test is a failure, leaving the weapon adrift. Archer decides this is an ideal opportunity to steal it and learn more about the technology.

Analysis

Some nice continuity here; Enterprise finds the weapon in the first place thanks to the bug they planted in the Kemocite shipment in "The Shipment", and Gralik is mentioned and credited with causing the test to fail by sabotaging the kemocite as he promised. The crew are still working to recover the information deleted from their computers in the previous episode. Shran references Archer's favour for him in "Cease Fire", and it's nice to see that he is becoming more of an ally even though his orders compelled him to double cross Archer this time.

There's nothing terribly new or original here. The Xindi weapon arc is trundling along after a couple of episodes where it receeded into the background. The double cross itself was pretty obvious, but then the episode didn't really make a big deal of trying to trick the audience here, showing us Shran's orders in advance. It's nice to see that Archer also anticipated it and had good a counter-plan ready to go.

It's becoming obvious that there is a system governing the behaviour of the Andorian antennae. Normally they point straight up and slightly to the sides. When an Andorian is really interested in something or someone they point towards that thing or person. When they are angry the antennae fold back almost flat against the skull; the latter is presumably so that they are less likely to be damaged in any fighting.


Copyright Graham Kennedy Page views : 1,900 Last updated : 2 Feb 2004